Added: Halimah Zamorano - Date: 08.09.2021 10:39 - Views: 20325 - Clicks: 3584
Try out PMC Labs and tell us what you think. Learn More.HIDE AND SEEK in my new house!
Physicians often are asked for advice about medical matters by relatives and friends. These range from requests for simple information to requests for medical opinion and judgment and more substantial involvement by the physician. I comment on the motivations and expectations of the requester and the physician, and the legal, ethical, and practical considerations related to such requests. I recommend: 1 Be clear about the expectations of the requester and yourself, including whether you are being asked for simple factual information, your medical judgment and opinion, or more substantial involvement in the situation.
This ranges from simply acting as interpreter or facilitator to offering medical advice to providing medical care. This discussion is about the more ambiguous portion of the range of requests from relatives and friends in which physicians are asked to act as informal medical consultants, a topic that has received little attention in the published literature.
It is not about issues related to the medical care of family and friends, including prescribing medications, which have been covered well in the literature 1 — 4. Although physicians handle most such requests well, occasionally the requests provoke misunderstandings and conflicts that could be mitigated or Seeking p t friend by attention to the dynamics of the transactions and adherence to some practical guidelines. Requests for medical advice begin for many of us as early as medical school when we return home for holiday vacations and our brother or high school friend wants to know what a pain or a rash means.
Later, when we become fully trained physicians, family members and friends ask us to help navigate the complexities of the health care system; to interpret symptoms, physical s, laboratory tests, and other medical information; to recommend a generalist or a specialist; to explain a diagnosis; and in other ways to act as a knowledgeable, sympathetic intermediary and medical resource. The relationship between the relative or friend and us may be close or distant, but the common thread is this: the requester is relying on us as professionals who have medical knowledge and familiarity with the medical system.
Sometimes we are asked to use our judgment or offer advice. For purposes of conceptualizing and discussing this issue, the following describes a range of requests for medical advice that physicians may receive from relatives and friends.
The progress generally from requests for simple information to requests for medical judgment and more substantial involvement by the physician. The are not cleanly separable, requests may fall into more than one category, and relatives and friends may ask something that is not covered by any category below.
Request for factual medical information e. How does prostate cancer develop? Request for recommendation about which physician to see e. Request for medical information plus some judgment e. How would I know if I had prostate cancer? Could you please talk with my doctor?
Request to encourage a third party to access medical care e. Request for medical judgment about a medical event e. Request for a medical opinion about the appropriateness of medical recommendations or the course of treatment e.
The family member or friend is motivated by one or more interests. The requester also may be searching, hoping, for a different answer in a threatening medical situation. Lack of access to medical care may stimulate the request. Physicians generally are motivated to respond by love, friendship, duty, and the desire to help.
They, too, simply may be curious.
Sometimes physicians feel they need to control the medical situation of their friend or relative because they think they possess the appropriate expertise or do not trust other physicians or the system to do the right thing. The expectations of the requester and the physician usually align and there is a mutual understanding of the role of the physician as provider of information, interpreter, and advisor and that the request is limited to the information that is sought.
Sometimes the expectations and understandings of the requester and the physician do not align. For example, the requester may not distinguish among physicians with regard to their medical expertise and view all MDs as capable of addressing most medical matters or the requester may expect the physician to continue to be involved in the situation when the physician feels his or her involvement is limited to the initial interaction.
In interacting with relatives and friends, physicians bring traditional ethical principles of the medical profession to bear. These are a mixture of the desire to do good and alleviate suffering beneficencean intent to minimize harm nonmaleficenceand the duty to provide care. We sometimes assume, often erroneously, because of the familiarity of a relationship, that medical information may be shared with others in the close circle of family or friends. Also, if the requester is speaking for another person in need of medical advice, the ethical prerogatives of that person as deserving confidentiality and as an autonomous individual need to be respected.
It is difficult to establish rigid rules of procedure for this, but physicians should be mindful of the need to preserve autonomy and confidentiality. Further, because of the ambiguity between confidentiality and openness in certain relationships, the physician may wonder, when a relative or friend is telling a personal medical story, whether this is something they should be talking about. Friends and relatives are not immune from suing physicians whom they consult informally 5. Typically, the scope and nature of the relationship are not explicitly agreed on at the outset.
Rather, the relationship evolves and is inferred from the communications and conduct of the physician and patient… Personally examining the patient or expecting payment for services—features typical of formal consults—would almost certainly establish a legal relationship with the patient.
Johnson advises physicians to approach relatives and friends who seek clinical Seeking p t friend with the same professional expertise and judgment as any other patient, to document the encounter, to ask the person to come to the office if an examination is necessary or records need to be reviewed, and to be mindful of HIPAA Health Insurance Portability and ability Act of rules 5.
What constitutes a physical examination would seem to be a matter of context and interpretation. To physicians, a physical examination ordinarily means a structured, albeit often limited, hands-on examination of the patient that usually occurs in a health care setting. However, an examination in the context of a social or family situation may be a focused appraisal of something that is readily evident, such as detecting jaundice, or easy to do, such as limited palpation or assessing t mobility. In such instances, a physician probably would not consider charging a fee. Requests for medical advice from relatives and friends generally come in the context of existing family ties or friendship and a history of trust and shared experiences.
These create an environment in which the requester feels that he or she has permission to approach the physician for medical advice and to which most physicians respond favorably. Usually the relative or friend is happy to receive the advice, and the physician is pleased to be of service. After all, that is what physicians are Seeking p t friend to do!
These generally salutary influences may be mitigated by concerns that the requester or the physician may have. Conversely, the requester may not be concerned about imposing on the physician, which may engender resentment by the physician.
Physicians differ in respect to this, but some may resent what they interpret as a violation of a safe zone or otherwise feel burdened by requests for medical advice from relatives and friends. Tensions may develop when the parties do not have a mutual implicit or explicit understanding of the expectations and limits of the transaction; the physician fears an awkward situation or the possibility of discord within the family or friendship; the requester seeks medical advice beyond the capability or comfort level of the physician; the physician gives advice that is misinterpreted, misused, not followed, or incorrect; the requester regards the physician as one of the responsible physicians in the case; the physician feels conflicted in multiple roles, e.
Further, prior experiences with the requester may raise caution, animosity, or otherwise condition the current request.
The last response could apply to several of the situations implied in the preceding responses and combined with them. But remember, I am your friend who happens to be a physician, and I think you can appreciate that that is different from being your physician.
I am your cousin who happens to be a physician, but I think you can appreciate that that is different from being your physician. Be clear about the expectations of the requester and yourself, including whether you are being asked for simple factual information, for your medical judgment, or to be more substantially involved. If for some reason you cannot respond to the request or have concerns, make that clear.
In close relationships, such as with a spouse, a parent,or sibling, it is a matter of judgment whether you explicitly express the extent of your initial and ongoing involvement and commitment. Treat your interactions with relatives or friends with the same professional expertise and judgment as you would any patient, even though those interactions may be informal.
Document the encounter with a brief note for your personal files, which can be useful if you have continuing interactions with your relative Seeking p t friend friend. Be aware that a structured physical examination and especially charging a fee strengthen the establishment of a legal relationship with the requester as your patient. Most requests for medical advice do not require a structured physical examination, but if you choose to examine the patient, you will need to decide whether the examination should take place in your office.
Be sure the requester approves the sharing of information, even in close relationships. Be aware of the potential conflict between your roles as a relative or friend and as a physician. Your professional judgment may be in conflict with your emotional judgment. Further, all physicians play a of different roles e.
National Center for Biotechnology InformationU. J Gen Intern Med. Published online Sep Gregory L. EastwoodMD. Author information Article notes Copyright and information Disclaimer. Corresponding author. This article has been cited by other articles in PMC. Abstract Physicians often are asked for advice about medical matters by relatives and friends. THE CONTEXT Requests for medical advice begin for many of us as early as medical school when we return home for holiday vacations and our brother or high school friend wants to know what a pain or a rash means. Acknowledgments Conflict of Interest None disclosed.Seeking p t friend
email: [email protected] - phone:(816) 165-4696 x 8345
When Relatives and Friends Ask Physicians for Medical Advice: Ethical, Legal, and Practical Considerations